Archive for October, 2011
Seahawks Secondary Player Grades
The funny thing about this group is that individually they all played pretty average with the exception of Kennard Cox (who stunk it up pretty bad) but as a group playing in the scheme of the defense they held the Browns to only 159 yards passing. I find myself torn at this point because these are individual player grades but at the same time their effort led to the production by the defense.
I think what I will do is leave out the sum of their play (at least for now) and just evaluate each player on his own.
1) Chris Maragos (C+)
Chris was signed from the practice squad earlier in the week.
He mad a nice tackle on special teams while covering a kick.
It is sad that I have him listed as the top grade here.
2) Richard Sherman, Walter Thurmond and Brandon Browner (C)
Last week: Richard B+, Walter B and Brandon B+
5) Kennard Cox (D)
Last week B-
Cox had a few plays where he had good coverage.
On the play when Josh Cribbs muffed the fair catch Kennard ran behind Cribbs but if he had stayed in front when Josh muffed the punt he would have been in a position to compete for the ball. He got called for the block in the back on Leo’s big punt return. I think it was a bogus call but the fact remains that Cox was reaching for the guy and gave them an opportunity to make a bad call. He should have kept his hands to himself there was nothing he could have done because he was out of position anyway. He had 2 missed tackles including one that would have been a sack.
1) Earl Thomas, Kam Chancellor and Jeron Johnson (C)
Last week: Earl B+, Kam A+ and Jeron B-
4) Atari Bigby (C-)
Last week C-
If he had only made one big play
He missed a tackle on a punt coverage.
Seahawks Linebacker Player Grades
1) David Hawthorne (A-)
Last week C
In the passing game he was able to record a sack, get and interception, have another play where he had excellent coverage and get pressure on the quarterback. In the running game he was able to shoot the gap and make a tackle for a loss and another tackle for short gain. On one play he took on the fullback in the hole and left the running back no where to go.
David was having a bit of trouble being too aggressive and jumping the run too early causing him to get caught out of position on a few running plays. On one play he did a terrible job in coverage.
2) Leroy Hill and KJ Wright (B)
Last week: Leroy C+ and KJ led the linebackers with a B+
Hill had a couple tackles for loss and a tackle for no gain. He got some pressure on the quarterback and did a good job for the most part in coverage. Wright had three tackles for short gain including one where he recognized Colt McCoy scrambling. He also had a tackle for a loss and a pass defensed.
Leroy missed a tackle and on a play action pass he was late getting out to the flat to cover the tight end. On KJ’s pass defense he should have intercepted the ball and he bit really hard on one play action and found himself out of position.
4) Malcolm Smith (C)
Last week he did not play.
Seahawks Defensive Line Player Grades
1) Brandon Mebane (A+)
Last week A+
Brandon had McCoy’s snap count down pat and was able to get a good jump off the ball all game. He hit the quarterback once and had three more quarterback pressures including a play where he did an excellent job on a stunt. Mebane was able to fight off blocks and make three tackles for short gain including a play while he was being double teamed. He also had a tackle for loss.
Te Seahawks cannot clone him.
2) Alan Branch and Chris Clemons (A-)
Last week: Alan A and Chris A+
Branch spent a lot of the game in the backfield. He was getting penetration in the passing game as well as the running game. He tipped a pass, batted one down and had two quarterback pressures. In the running game he was creating problems by being in the backfield but did not record any tackles for loss although he managed a tackle for no gain. Like Mebane, Clemons was getting of the snap well. He recorded 2 sacks in the game and was able to hit the quarterback on another play. He had a tackle for a loss and a tackle for no gain in the running game.
Alan lost outside contain on the quarterback when the defense was blitzing from the opposite side allowing Colt McCoy to run away from the two free blitzers. On one running play Chris was unable to fight off a block by the tight end and on a passing play he was sent into zone coverage but did not drop deep enough.
4) Anthony Hargrove and Raheem Brock (B)
Last week: Anthony C+ and Raheem B-
Anthony was getting a good jump of the snap and that helped him get to the quarterback and hit him a couple times. He was also able to get run penetration. Raheem had a couple quarterback pressures and also showed a nice spin move that helped him make a tackle for short gain.
Hargrove missed a block on a kick return.
6) Clinton McDonald (B-)
Last week B-
He was able to get some pressure in the running game and had a quarterback pressure.
There were no glaring mistakes made on his part.
7) Red Bryant
He had a stellar game with 2 blocked field goals but after losing his cool, getting ejected from the game and costing the Seahawks one last possession he will receive no grade this week.
Last week A-
Wide Receiver and Tight Ends Player Grades
1) Mike Williams (B-)
Last week he missed due to injury
Mike did a nice job while run blocking and he made a nice move after a catch to pick up a first down.
Williams only caught the one pass.
2) Sidney Rice and Golden Tate (C+)
Last week: They both had B’s
Sidney had a nice block down field and a 38 yard reception that would have been a touchdown if the pass was accurate. Golden made a nice catch with a defensive back draped all over him.
Rice was unable to hold his block on a screen pass. The pass that Tate caught was the only one thrown to him in the game.
4) Doug Baldwin (C-)
Last week he led the group with an A+
He was tackled late in the fourth quarter while he was on his route
This isn’t his typical week
He dropped a very catch-able ball and was called for Pass Interference but if you watch the corners feet you can see that he lost his footing and his feet slipped out from under him.
5) Ben Obomanu (D+)
Last week B+
The Seahawks no longer need to count on him to produce.
He made a poor adjustment on an under-thrown ball. If he had he made the adjustment he would have had a big reception. Ben dropped a pass on third down that would have been a first down on the final drive.
1) Cameron Morrah (C+)
This was his first game this season
He made a nice block down field and did a nice job seling his blocks on play action and then sneaking out into his route.
Morrah missed a block during a screen pass and the play resulted in a loss.
2) Anthony McCoy (C)
Last week F+
Quarterback and Running Back Player Grades
Charlie Whitehurst (F-)
Last week B+ in almost half a game after replacing Tarvaris Jackson (injury)
Charlie did a good job handling the high snaps from backup center Lemuel Jeanpierre. He showed and ability to fit the ball into small windows and get it out in a hurry at times.
Whitehurst did have trouble handling one of the high snaps. He was throwing into a lot of coverage and should have had more interceptions but he was lucky that the Browns secondary cannot catch balls that hit them in their hands. On his final pass of the game he threw a ball (on fourth down) that had 0% chance of being completed. There were no open receivers at the time but he threw it to the worst possible one. The others had a low chance of success but at least there was some chance. He struggled finding the open receiver and on multiple occasions threw the ball to someone who was covered when he had a receiver open. At the goal line he threw the ball out of bounds in the direction of Michael Robinson but he had Cameron Morrah at the 1-yard line with a couple steps on the line backer. That should have been an easy touchdown but Charlie never made an attempt. He had a lot of trouble hanging onto the ball when he was sacked or at one point even when there was no pressure on him and he lost control of the ball while attempting to throw it. He threw an interception on the play after Leon’s SHOULD BE touchdown. They had great field position and the quarterback needs to show poise in that situation not frustration like Whitehurst did. Late in the game he had Sidney Rice wide open and all he needed to do was throw the ball on target but instead threw the ball so that Rice was forced out of bounds. They still got a big completion but that play should have been a touchdown. He started to panic in the pocket towards the end of the game.
1) Leon Washington (A-)
Laste week he led the backs with an A-
First, to get it out of the way, he had a punt return for a touchdown. The block in the back was a bogus call and I am not about to take that return away from Washington because he deserves it. What I will say though is he shouldn’t have been show boating before he got in the end zone and taken that big hit. It kinda reminded me of last year when he was show boating and got tackled just short of the end zone. He needs to stop that. When he got the ball in his hands he did everything in his power to make something happen. He averaged 5.6-yards per carry and was showing his wicked ability to cut and make people miss. At times he just decided to run over a would-be tackler. He showed patience setting up his blocks and vision finding cut back lanes. He also showed the speed needed to get to the edge and that he has an ability to pick up the blitz.
He only had 7 carries and took a kick off back to the 14-yard line. If you are going to take the ball out of the end zone on a kick off you better get back to the 20 at least.
2) Justin Forsett (B-)
Last week B-
He showed his ability to make hard cuts and make people miss. He did a nice job picking up the blitz and giving his quarterback more time to throw.
He only averaged 2.9-yards per carry and part of the reason was because he was hesitating to hit the hole. On special teams he had a missed block during a kick return.
3) Michael Robinson (D+)
Last week C+
On Leon’s punt return for the touchdown he had a nice block that sprung him at the beginning of the return. He had a couple nice run blocks.
He struggled most of the game. Michael had a missed tackle on punt coverage and one on kick coverage. He missed a block on a kick return but the worst mistake was at the goal line when he lead the running back into the hole and dove on the ground blocking no one. Had he blocked one of the two defenders bearing down on the running back it would have probably been a touchdown.
Seahawks Player Grades
They all did a nice job selling the play action.
1) Russell Okung (B-)
Last week B-
He played his best game since being injured in the preseason so hopefully it is a sign that his ankle is feeling better. Russell had a few nice blocks both in the running game and in pass protection.
Okung lost his block on one running play and he had trouble picking up a stunt.
2) Robert Gallery and James Carpenter (C+)
Last week: Robert did not play and James had an F
Gallery was solid when he was asked to move around. If he was pulling or being asked to block at the second level he was spot on. At the beginning of the game Carpenter was getting of the snap extremely quickly. He blocked well in the running game including a play where he was blocking two defenders at the same time. He wasn’t able to hold the block long but for a bit he had one blocked with each hand.
Unfortunately when Robert was asked to line up and block the guy in front of him he struggled a lot of the time. As stated above James was getting off the snap well but then he started jumping before the snap and got called for two false starts on the same drive. He missed a cut block but reached out and grabbed the foot of the defender and tackled him. That play was not called but it easily could have been. James gave up a sack when he was beat by a double move on the inside.
4) John Moffitt (C)
Last week B-
5) Lemuel Jeanpierre (F)
Last week (playing in place of Robert Gallery) C+
Jeanpierre had a pancake block on a run at the goal line, too bad no one else blocked on that play.
Four snaps were too high and he is lucky that Charlie Whitehurst was able to keep them from being disasters. He had trouble sealing runnings games and blocking in the running game when asked to block 1:1 at times.
Seahawks Player Grades from the Giants game.
First of all let me apologize for not getting the grades done like usually. I have been very sick and unable to sit at the computer to type them out.
I was able to do all the game notes and I have all the information I would normally put out but I think in the interest of getting the grades out I will post the actual grade for every player and if I get a request about why a players grade is what it is I will add to this post.
Thank you all for your patience.
The last grade I gave out was the quarterbacks so I will start here with the running backs
Last week he led the running backs with a B+
2) Marshawn Lynch (B+)
Last week C+
3) Justin Forsett (B-)
Last week B
4) Michael Robinson (C+)
Last week C-
He did a very nice job on special teams while blocking on punt returns and getting downfield in a hurry on a kick return and getting in on a tackle inside the Giants 15-yard line.
He ran into the back of his own player and fumbled the ball near the giants goal line. Darrell Bevell should have never handed him the ball three straight times but it is his job to hold onto the ball every time his number is called.
1) Doug Baldwin (A+)
Last week he led the receivers with an A-
2) Ben Obomanu (B+)
Last week B
3) Sidney Rice and Golden Tate (B)
Last week Sidney had a C+ and Golden did not receive a grade.
Last week B
His grade was extremely limited this week because he was injured on the Seahawks seventh offensive play.
2) Anthony McCoy (F+)
Last week C+
Last week: Brandon had a B+ and Chris had a B-
3) Alan Branch (A)
Last week he led the unit with an A
4) Red Bryant (A-)
Last week C
5) Raheem Brock and Clinton McDonald (B-)
Last week; Raheem B+ and Clinton an A-
7) Anthony Hargrove (C+)
Last week he was last of the defensive line with a C-
8) Al Woods and Jameson Konz (C)
This was the first week either player was graded.
1) KJ Wright (B+)
Last week C+
2) Leroy Hill and David Vobora (C+)
Last week: Leroy C+ and David was signed on October 4th.
4) David Hawthorne (C)
Last week D+
5) Aaron Curry (D-)
Last week he led the linebackers with a B-
Last week: Brandon C and Richard led the corners with a C+
3) Walter Thurmond (B)
Last week he was not graded
4) Kennard Cox (B-)
Last week D-
1) Kam Chancellor (A+)
Last week Atari Bigby started in his place due to injury
2) Earl Thomas (B+)
Last week C+
3) Jeron Johnson (B-)
Last week he led all safeties with a B-
4) Atari Bigby (C-)
Last week D+
Seahawks Quarterback Player Grades
1) Charlie Whitehurst (B+)
This was his first action this year.
Charlie had several really well placed passes. One was the quick slant to Sidney Rice and another one was the touchdown pass to Doug Baldwin. He did a good job avoiding sacks either by using his legs to buy time or throwing the ball away. His decision making was quick which allowed him to plant his back foot and throw the ball.
On one play he didn’t recognize a blitz and took a big hit from his blind side. One of the passes where he threw the ball away he had locked onto a receiver and didn’t go through his progressions. If he had he gone through them he would have seen that Anthony McCoy was open underneath.
2) Tarvaris Jackson (C+)
Last week A-
He did a good job leading his receivers to give them a chance to catch the ball in stride. Tarvaris had a few passes where he didn’t have much of a window and had excellent ball placement. Jackson was doing a pretty good job going through his progressions and had a touchdown pass.
Two straight passes he threw into double coverage the second of which Zach Miller got hurt from a hit to his head. New York Giants Safety Kenny Phillis was fined $20,000 for the hit on Miller. He floated a ball and made a poor decision on another to throw a ball to the outside that had little chance of going well. That ball was intercepted.
Seahawks Offensive Line Player Grades
1) Paul McQuinstan (B+)
He went from worst last week to first this week.
He was solid in the running game except for one play. Paul showed strength pushing a defender down the line and opening a big running lane. He got good push at the goal line on Marshawn Lynch’s touchdown. He had a pancake and was able to seal running lanes. He showed athleticism by getting to the second level to block in the running game. McQuinstan did a good job in pass pro as well including working with Okung while defenders were stunting.
He got called for holding, missed a cut block and was unable to hold one run block that caused a takle for no gain.
2) Russell Okung and John Moffitt (B-)
Last week: Russell C- and John led the unit with an A-
Russell did a nice job early in the game clearing a passing lane on a short pass. He had some plays where he really held strong in pass pro and did a good job working with McQuinstan against stunting defenders. For the most part Okung was strong while blocking in the running game. On Marshawn Lynch’s touchdown run from the 1-yard line he got good push driving the defender into the end zone. He had a pancake and did a nice job sealing some running lanes. He showed toughness trying to play through cramping but eventually had to be pulled from the game. John did a good job working with James Carpenter as a unit. On the quarterback sneak he was able to get good push that gave Tarvaris plenty of room to get over the first down line. He showed the extreme power he posses when he pushed his defender into the line and collapse the whole line. Later in the game he had a nice cut block.
Okung reached for Osi Umenyiora instead of keeping his feet under him. On that play Osi easily beat Russell and stripped the ball away from Lynch from behind. He was beat for two sacks and got the quarterback hit a couple more times. On one play John was working with Carpenter and they could not move the defender out of the running lane and on one play he got pushed into the backfield while run blocking. Moffitt gave up a sack and got beat to the inside by on a passing play. After that play he came off the field and went back into the locker room to get IV fluids.
4) Lemuel Jeanpierre (C+)
Last week he did not receive a grade
He showed awareness on a passing play when James Carpenter was getting beat on the outside. He ran around Carpenter and laid out the pass rusher knocking him to the ground. Lemuel showed some power when he pushed a defender 5-yards down the field during a running play. He had a nice block on the Safety Kick return that helped spring Leon Washington to a decent return.
On a passing play he got bull rushed and pushed back into the quarterback and on a running play he was not able to seal a running lane against a linebacker.
5) Max Unger (D)
Last week B
He had a vey inconsistent game.
At times he did a very good job getting to the second level to block in the running game. He was able to seal running lanes and open holes. At times he was solid in the passing game including a play where he had a nice cut block on a wide receiver screen.
As a center his first job is to snap the ball and get it to his quarterback. Three times while in the shotgun he had snaps that were off target. A couple times he couldn’t get blocks at the second level, one of which he couldn’t get off his initial block (I would assume there was a hold but you couldn’t see it from the camera angle). He missed a cut block on a quarterback scramble that led to Jackson getting tackled. Max had some trouble keeping the running lanes open long enough for the running back to get through them and he had a false start.
6) James Carpenter (F)
Last week B+
He worked well with John Moffitt. He was able to seal the edge on Marshawn’s 47-yard run and had good push on a 3rd and 1. At times he held up in the passing game.
At times James had trouble sealing the running lane. He missed a couple of cut blocks, one of which led to pressure on the quarterback. He was beat inside and outside in pass pro giving up 2 sacks, getting the quarterback hit once and pressured three more times. He picked up a false start penalty.
Seahawks Trade Linebacker Aaron Curry
If you are one of those people who thought the Seahawks should lose last years game at home against the Rams to get a better draft pick this is one example of why you are wrong.
It started April 25, 2009, when Linebacker Aaron Curry was drafted by the Seattle Seahawks with the 4th overall pick in the draft.
Curry was considered the “can’t miss” prospect in the draft. He was the most “NFL ready” player and more than a few thought he was the “best player” in the draft, not just at his position but player period.
It’s not every day that the team with the 4th overall pick has a chance to draft the “best player” so it was very exciting when Seattle came on the clock and he was still available.
After being drafted by the Seahawks he was an instant hit with fans and media a like. He came in a soft spoken, mild mannered young man who seemed very grateful for his opportunity to be a Seattle Seahawk.
Fast forward to October 12, 2011, and you see a player who many, including myself, are very happy to see leave.
Maybe Curry can find that player he was supposed to be now that he is an Oakland Raider. Maybe he will regain his focus and his passion for the game in the Black Hole. It was clear that it wasn’t going to happen here.
Many people are calling him one of the biggest bust in franchise history but when I looked at some of the other draft busts the Seahawks have had I can’t put Curry in the same category as them for the simple fact that the Seahawks were able to get another team to trade for him.
The Seahawks appear to be getting two conditional draft picks; one late round pick this year and a mid-round pick next.